July 4, 1851

John and Fanny French Open a Hotel on Mt. Holyoke Summit

PRIMARY SOURCE: Newspaper, 1841
Share this story

On this day in 1851, John and Fanny French opened a two-story, eight-room hotel on the summit of Mt. Holyoke. Several hundred people attended the opening. By the 1860s, tourists could choose to ride a tram all the way to the top — they disembarked right in the hotel — or ascend the mountain by foot, horseback, or coach, and finish by climbing a 522-step stone stairway. In its heyday, the hotel at the summit of Mt. Holyoke had many famous guests. Singer Jenny Lind, the "Swedish Nightingale," gave a performance there in 1851. Alexander Graham Bell was a regular visitor. After the turn of the century, the automobile brought dramatic changes to what Americans did on the weekends and for vacations. The hotel at the summit of Mt. Holyoke was one of many mountain-top resorts that declined in popularity due to the automobile's rise.

In its heyday, the hotel at the summit of Mt. Holyoke had many famous guests.

State officials' decision in 1965 to burn what was left of the Mt. Holyoke cable railway marked the end of an era. Once an innovative means of transporting tourists to the summit of one of the region's best-known peaks, the tram had become a safety hazard in a popular state park.

In the 1820s, New Englanders began to view mountains as more than obstacles to travel. As Massachusetts became more urban and industrial, natural landscapes — especially mountains — acquired new significance. They offered the opportunity for recreation, inspiration, artistic creation, and simple sightseeing.

The first Massachusetts mountain to be developed as a resort was Mt. Holyoke in Hadley. In 1821 Willis Pease bought nine acres near the summit for $27. He built a hut and advertised in the local paper that he had made arrangements for the public on the summit of Mt. Holyoke. Visitors were promised spirits, rum, cognac, gin, rum, wines — at a price twice what was charged in the valley — "Spanish segars," and other refreshments. Pease sold the land three years later for $600 —far more than local farmers thought it was worth; the land was sold again in 1826, this time for $1,500.

Willis Pease and the other early developers of the summit site were seeking to capitalize on the growing number of people whose idea of a pleasant outing was a mountain climb. From the summit of Mt. Holyoke, they beheld a landscape of dense woods, rugged hills, tidy towns, and fertile farmland stretching along the Connecticut River.

Moving at a 38-degree angle, riders had the sensation of being pulled almost straight up.

By the 1840s, there was an alternative to hiking. In 1846, a carriage road was built up the western slope. In 1849 newlyweds John and Fanny French visited the summit. Confident of its commercial potential, they bought the property and began constructing a two-story, eight-room hotel. When it opened on July 4, 1851, several hundred people attended the dedication.

With the closest source of water halfway down the mountain, John French built a wooden railway to haul barrels of water up the track. Power was provided by a horse hitched to a circling crank at the top.

French soon realized that, properly equipped, the tram could also transport people. He installed the body of a sleigh, and passengers were soon being carried over 600 feet up the mountain. Moving at a 38-degree angle, riders had the sensation of being pulled almost straight up.

In 1856, French replaced the horse with a steam engine. As more and more visitors used the tramway, he covered it with a roof and added two six-passenger cars.

By the 1860s, tourists could choose to ride the tram all the way to the top — they disembarked right in the hotel — or ascend the mountain by foot, horseback, or coach, and finish by climbing a 522-step stone stairway.

For much of the nineteenth century, the Mt. Holyoke summit was among the region's most popular destinations. First came artists, such as Thomas Cole, who painted a famous picture of the Connecticut River "Oxbow" in 1836. Writers were also inspired by the panorama of mountains, valley, fields, towns, river, and sky. Ralph Waldo Emerson, Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, and Emily Dickinson were among the many writers who visited the summit.

"I have been all over England, have traveled through all the Highlands of Scotland; I have passed up and down the Rhine, have ascended Mt. Blanc, and stood on the Campagna at Rome, but never have seen anything so surpassingly lovely as this."

Dickinson grew up in nearby Amherst and attended Mount Holyoke Female Seminary. An annual hike up the mountain was one of the college's very first traditions. Their teachers believed that the mountain scenery would nourish students' souls and improve their characters while the climb strengthened their bodies. Mount Holyoke College continues to observe Mountain Day today.

In its heyday, the hotel at the summit of Mt. Holyoke had many famous guests. Singer Jenny Lind, the "Swedish Nightingale," gave a performance there in 1851. Alexander Graham Bell was a regular visitor. One 1860 entry in the guest register records a visit from Abraham Lincoln. Many years later, a handwriting expert declared the signature a forgery, but the fact that Lincoln might indeed have visited Mt. Holyoke attests to its fame.

By mid-century, the view was being compared to sights in more exotic parts of the world. In 1847, Massachusetts Senator Charles Sumner claimed, "I have been all over England, have traveled through all the Highlands of Scotland; I have passed up and down the Rhine, have ascended Mt. Blanc, and stood on the Campagna at Rome, but never have seen anything so surpassingly lovely as this."

What made the prospect from Mt. Holyoke so satisfying was the combination of rugged mountains and well-tended farms and villages. Fitted out in "the most modern style," the hotel provided the trappings of civilization from which to enjoy the view.

As early as the 1920s, people could drive to the top of Mt. Holyoke.

In 1871 John and Fanny French sold the hotel to investor John Dwight, who had long summered on the mountain. The Frenches continued to manage the establishment. Dwight re-named it the Holyoke Hotel and added a large four-story addition. By the 1890s the dining room could accommodate 200 guests at a time. There were tennis and croquet courts and other amenities commonly found at late nineteenth century resorts.

After the turn of the century, the automobile brought dramatic changes to what Americans did on the weekends and for vacations. As early as the 1920s, people could drive to the top of Mt. Holyoke. The problem was, they could also drive to more distant and exciting destinations. The Mt. Holyoke House was one of many mountain-top resorts that fell out of favor.

As the popularity of New England's mountain resorts declined, so did the condition of the Mt. Holyoke Hotel. The wooden tramway continued to operate, but fewer and fewer people chose to ride in it. The hotel was already struggling when Northampton businessman Joseph Skinner acquired it in 1916.

Over the next ten years, Skinner modernized the building, installing plumbing and electrical service, but it was too late. The era of the summit house was over. The great hurricane of 1938 devastated the property. The 1894 annex was a complete loss. Two years later, Skinner donated the entire 273-acre site to the Commonwealth as a park.

Local groups that advocated restoring the historic tramway were unsuccessful. In 1965, the state decided that the deteriorating track was becoming a safety hazard. On February 17th, employees of the Department of Natural Resources burned the cable railway to the ground. The loading platform can still be seen in the building, which the state park system restored in the 1980s.

If You Go

The state Department of Conservation and Recreation has restored the surviving part of the Summit House. It is in Skinner State Park in Hadley.

Location

This Mass Moment occurred in the Western region of Massachusetts.

Sources

Ethan Carr's essay, "Preserving Mt. Holyoke," is included in Cultivating a Past: Essays on the History of Hadley, Massachusetts, edited by Marla R. Miller (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 2009).

Related Moments

Mass Moments is a project of Mass Humanities, whose mission is to support programs that use history, literature, philosophy, and the other humanities disciplines to enhance and improve civic life throughout the Commonwealth.

Please consider helping us towards our goals with a donation today.

Interested in sponsoring Mass Moments?

Please add 1 and 7.